A tax appeal is a formal challenge to an assessment or adjudication order. Income tax appeals go first to the Commissioner (Appeals), then the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal and the High Court; GST appeals go to the Appellate Authority, then the GST Appellate Tribunal and the High Court. Peter and Co., Laxmi Nagar, Delhi, drafts grounds, statements of facts and paper books and represents you.
Key facts
- Income tax first appeal
- Commissioner (Appeals), also called CIT(A), by electronic Form 35 under the Income-tax Act, 1961
- Income tax second appeal
- Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), the final fact-finding forum
- Income tax third stage
- High Court, on a substantial question of law
- GST first appeal
- Appellate Authority under section 107 of the CGST Act
- GST second appeal
- GST Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT), then the High Court on questions of law
- Pre-deposit
- Part of the disputed GST tax is generally required for GST appeals; stay of income tax demand is sought separately
- Our work
- Grounds of appeal, statement of facts, paper book, written submissions, hearing, rectification
- Service mode
- In person at our Laxmi Nagar office by appointment, or online across India
Peter and Co. provides income tax appeal and GST appeal services from our office in Laxmi Nagar, Delhi, for individuals, professionals, traders, companies, firms and LLPs who have received an adverse order and want it reviewed by a higher authority. An appeal is not a second reply to the notice. It is a structured legal document that points out what the officer got wrong in fact or law, and it must be filed in the right forum, in the right form and in time.
This page explains the appeal ladder for income tax and GST, how the grounds of appeal and statement of facts are drafted, what a paper book and written submission are, how a demand can be kept in check while the appeal is pending, and what limits apply. It reflects the position as of October 2026 and is written in general terms. If you are searching for a tax appeal consultant near you in East Delhi, Shahdara, Preet Vihar or Karkardooma, our team can meet you by appointment or work online anywhere in India.
What is a tax appeal and when should you file one?
A tax appeal is a statutory remedy by which a taxpayer asks a higher authority to set aside or modify an order of an assessing or adjudicating officer. You should consider an appeal when an order creates a tax, interest, penalty or refund consequence that you believe is wrong on the facts or the law.
An appeal is available only because the Act provides it, so the right forum, the right form and the time limit are fixed by law. If the order contains a mistake apparent on the record, such as a calculation error, a rectification application may be quicker; if the dispute is about substance, an appeal is the proper course. For notices still pending before an order, see our pages on income tax litigation and GST litigation.
Peter and Co. begins every appeal engagement with an order review. We read the order, the notice and the earlier reply, check the date of communication and the limitation, estimate the merit of each ground and tell you where the case is strong and where it is weak. Some orders are better accepted or settled than appealed, and we say so plainly.
Who needs an income tax appeal consultant or GST appeal consultant?
Anyone who has received an assessment order, a penalty order, an adjudication order, a refund rejection or a registration cancellation order that they wish to contest needs advice on appeal before the time limit runs out. The following situations are common.
- Salaried and individual taxpayers with additions made in a scrutiny or reassessment order, for example on cash deposits, capital gains or disallowed deductions.
- Businesses and professionals facing disallowances, estimated profits or penalty orders.
- Companies and firms with transfer-of-ownership, loan or share premium additions and large demands.
- GST registered persons with confirmed demands for tax, interest or penalty, denied input tax credit, or rejected refunds.
- Taxpayers who got an ex-parte order because a notice was missed.
- Those with an order from an Income Tax Department or GST authority that is still unpaid and attracts recovery action.
If you are unsure whether the order you have is appealable, send it to us. Not every communication is an order; an intimation, for example, may be rectified before it is appealed, and our team will tell you which category yours belongs to.
What is the appeal ladder for income tax and GST?
Both income tax and GST follow a three-tier ladder: a first appeal before an appellate authority, a second appeal before a tribunal, and a final appeal to the High Court on questions of law. The table summarises the forums as they stand in October 2026.
| Stage | Income tax | GST |
|---|---|---|
| First appeal | Commissioner (Appeals), CIT(A), by Form 35 on the e-filing portal | Appellate Authority under section 107 of the CGST Act, filed on the GST portal |
| Second appeal | Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), by appeal and memorandum of appeal | GST Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT) |
| Third stage | High Court, on a substantial question of law | High Court, on questions of law, as the Act provides |
| Nature of review | CIT(A) and ITAT can review facts and law | Appellate Authority and GSTAT can review facts and law |
| High Court review | Law only, not fresh facts | Law only, not fresh facts |
The Income-tax Act, 2025 replaces the Income-tax Act, 1961 from 1 April 2026, but appeals against orders passed under the 1961 Act continue under its provisions. Our team maps the old and new provisions for your matter and does not assume the numbering is the same. The GST Appellate Tribunal has been brought into operation in stages, so we confirm the current bench, filing procedure and any transitional arrangement before filing at that level.
How does an income tax appeal before the CIT(A) work?
An appeal before the Commissioner (Appeals), often called a CIT(A) appeal, is the first appeal against an assessment, reassessment, penalty or certain other orders. It is filed electronically in Form 35 on the Income Tax Department e-filing portal, with grounds of appeal, a statement of facts and the order appealed against.
Under the 1961 Act, the usual time to file is 30 days from the date of service of the notice of demand or communication of the order, and the Commissioner may admit a late appeal if there was sufficient cause for the delay. We confirm the time limit and the date of service for your order, because the period is short and counted from a specific date.
What the CIT(A) can do
- Confirm, reduce, enhance or annul the assessment, within the limits of the Act.
- Call for a remand report from the assessing officer on new evidence.
- Admit additional evidence in specified circumstances, which is why we explain at the outset why a document was not produced earlier.
The CIT(A) appeal is the best place to put the full factual case on record, since later forums are often limited by what was argued here. Our team prepares the grounds, the facts and an organised bundle of documents, and tracks hearing notices on the portal. Responses to hearing notices are filed on the portal, and we diarise each date.
What is an ITAT appeal and how does the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal work?
An ITAT appeal is a second appeal to the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal against an order of the CIT(A), or in certain cases against other specified orders. The Tribunal is an independent body and is the last forum that can re-examine the facts, so it is often the decisive stage of a tax dispute.
Under the 1961 Act, the usual time to appeal to the Tribunal is 60 days from the date the order is communicated, and a further cross-objection window exists for the other side. Late appeals can be admitted where there is sufficient cause. We verify the dates on the order and the benches that cover Delhi before filing.
An ITAT appeal is argued on the grounds raised, a paper book and written submissions. Either party can raise new legal points that arise from the record, and, in appropriate cases, the Tribunal may admit additional evidence. A stay of the demand can be requested from the Tribunal while the appeal is pending, which is explained below. We prepare the memorandum of appeal, the grounds, the paper book index and the submission note, and represent you at the hearing as the Tribunal\'s rules permit.
When can an income tax or GST matter go to the High Court?
A High Court appeal lies only where the case raises a substantial question of law, in the case of income tax, or a question of law in the case of GST, as the statute prescribes. The High Court does not re-weigh evidence the way the CIT(A), ITAT or GST Appellate Authority can.
For income tax, an appeal from the ITAT order to the High Court is generally filed within the limit set by the Act, and the appellant must frame the question of law in the memorandum. For GST, the Act provides for appeal to the High Court from the order of the State or National Bench of the Appellate Tribunal on a question of law, also within a stated period. Because these provisions are amended and the practice differs between High Courts, we confirm the limit and the court rules in each case.
A High Court appeal normally needs an advocate to appear. Peter and Co. prepares the tax-side analysis, the facts and the questions of law and coordinates with counsel where the matter reaches this stage, so that you do not have to explain the case twice.
How does a GST appeal before the Appellate Authority work?
A GST appeal is filed with the Appellate Authority under section 107 of the CGST Act against an order of the adjudicating authority, such as a demand order, a refund rejection or a registration cancellation. It is filed electronically on the GST portal in the prescribed form, with the order, grounds and statement of facts, and the required pre-deposit.
The first appeal must generally be filed within three months from the date the order is communicated, and the Appellate Authority may condone a further limited period if it is satisfied there was sufficient cause. We check the exact date on which your order was communicated, because that date drives the limit. Appeal against a refund order or a registration order follows the same section, but the facts and documents differ.
Pre-deposit for a GST appeal
To file a GST appeal, the appellant generally must pay the full admitted tax, interest, fine, fee and penalty, plus a prescribed percentage of the disputed tax, subject to a ceiling set by law. Recovery of the balance disputed amount is kept in abeyance while the appeal is pending. The percentages and caps have been revised from time to time, so we confirm them from the current Act and notifications.
The Appellate Authority hears the appellant, can call for further evidence, and passes an order confirming, modifying or annulling the order, but cannot refer the case back to the adjudicating authority for fresh decision. A second appeal lies to the GST Appellate Tribunal. If your case is still at the notice stage, our GST litigation team handles the reply.
What are pre-deposit, stay of demand and condonation of delay?
Pre-deposit is a part payment of the disputed amount made as a condition of appeal; stay of demand is a protection against recovery of the unpaid balance while the appeal is pending; and condonation of delay is the forum\'s discretion to admit an appeal filed after the limit if the delay is explained. Each has its own rules.
| Concept | Income tax | GST |
|---|---|---|
| Pre-deposit | Filing an appeal before CIT(A) does not require a fixed pre-deposit, but the demand remains payable unless stayed | A prescribed percentage of the disputed tax is generally payable to file the first appeal, with a ceiling |
| Stay of demand | An application is made to the Assessing Officer and, if needed, to a higher authority or the Tribunal; practice often links stay with payment of a part of the demand | Recovery of the balance is generally kept in abeyance after the pre-deposit while the appeal is pending |
| Condonation | Late appeal admitted if sufficient cause is shown, by affidavit or application | A limited additional period may be allowed on sufficient cause at the first appeal; later stages follow the Act |
Condonation is not a right. The explanation must be honest, specific and supported, and repeated or unexplained delay is often refused. If the limit is close, it is safer to file in time than to rely on condonation. For a stay, we prepare a short application with the financial position, the merits and the prejudice from recovery. Percentages and instructions change, so we confirm them before advising.
How are grounds of appeal, the statement of facts and the paper book drafted?
An appeal is drafted in four parts: the grounds of appeal, the statement of facts, the paper book of documents and the written submissions. The quality of these papers shapes how the appellate authority understands the case before the first hearing.
Grounds of appeal
Grounds are short numbered statements of what is wrong with the order, such as an addition made without basis, a failure to consider a reply, a breach of natural justice, or a misreading of the law. They should be specific, not general, and cover each addition or demand separately. Grounds not raised can be difficult to add later, so we plan them with care and keep an alternative ground wherever it is legitimate.
Statement of facts
The statement of facts is a clear, dated narrative: who you are, what return or reply you filed, what the department did and why it is disputed. It must be consistent with the order and the documents. Our team writes it in plain language so that an officer reading it for the first time understands the case in a few minutes.
Paper book and written submissions
- A paper book is an indexed, page-numbered compilation of the documents relied on, such as the return, computation, bank statements, agreements and earlier replies.
- Written submissions summarise each ground with the facts, the law and relevant judgments, and are filed before or at the hearing.
- A case-law compilation is added where the point is legal, and each judgment is checked for current validity.
Additional evidence should be explained at the time it is filed, with reasons why it was not produced earlier. We never file documents we have not verified with you.
What happens at the appeal hearing, and how does rectification work after the order?
At the hearing, the appellate authority takes up the grounds one by one, asks questions on the facts and hears the department\'s representative. We attend with the paper book and written submissions, answer questions and, where required, file further papers within the time allowed. Hearings may be physical or through video, and notices are served on the portal, so we monitor the account regularly.
After the order, read it for what is decided, what is remanded and what is still against you. Three follow-ups are possible: pay or adjust the demand, apply for rectification of a mistake apparent from the record, or move to the next appeal. Rectification is for obvious errors, such as a computation slip or an overlooked document, and must be applied for within the period in the Act. It is not a way of reopening the merits.
If the order is partly in your favour, the department may also appeal, so the file should stay open until the limit for further appeals has passed. For income tax, effect to the appellate order is given by the assessing officer, and we follow up and check that the revised demand or refund is correct on the portal.
What are the common mistakes in tax appeals?
The most common mistakes are filing late, filing without a full factual record and omitting grounds. Each can limit what the appellate forum is able to do for you.
- Counting time from the wrong date, such as the order date instead of the date of service or communication.
- Not paying the required pre-deposit in a GST appeal, which can make the appeal defective.
- Ignoring recovery. An appeal does not automatically stop recovery of income tax demand; a stay must be sought.
- Weak or generic grounds that do not address each addition.
- Producing evidence only at the last hearing without a reason why it was not produced earlier.
- Not tracking portal notices, leading to an ex-parte hearing.
- Appealing without reading the order, or confusing an intimation with an order.
- Expecting a result rather than preparing for one; appellate outcomes depend on facts and law.
A quick order review before the limit runs out costs far less than a lost appeal, so share the order with us as soon as you receive it.
What affects the cost of tax appeal services, and why choose Peter and Co. in Laxmi Nagar, Delhi?
The fee for an appeal depends on the forum, the number of additions or demands, the volume of documents, the legal complexity, the number of hearings and whether the stay and the later stages are included. We do not publish amounts because they would mislead; we quote in writing after reading the order. Pre-deposit, court fees and tribunal filing fees, if any, are paid to the government and are separate from professional fees.
Peter and Co. is a tax, audit and compliance firm at Office No. 816, 8th Floor, Laxmi Deep Building, Laxmi Nagar District Centre, Delhi 110092; phone and WhatsApp +91 98911 05177, office hours Monday to Saturday, 10:00 to 19:00. We meet clients in person by appointment from Laxmi Nagar, Shahdara, Preet Vihar, Mayur Vihar, Anand Vihar, Karkardooma, Krishna Nagar, Noida and Ghaziabad, and work online across India.
Limitations and what we cannot promise
We cannot promise that an appeal will succeed, that a stay will be granted, that a delay will be condoned or that the demand will be reduced. These depend on the facts, the evidence, the law and the view of the appellate authority. We also cannot extend a statutory limit. Some forums, such as the High Court, require an advocate, and we will say so at the start.
Related services
Appeals sit at the end of a chain that begins with a notice. Our income tax litigation and GST litigation teams handle the notice and assessment stage; tax audit, GST filing and tax advisory reduce the chance of a dispute. See all services or contact us.
This page is general information, not legal advice; rules change, so we confirm the current position before acting on your case.
Documents required for an income tax or GST appeal
- The order appealed against, with the notice of demand and the date and mode of service or communication
- The show cause notice, assessment notices and all replies filed earlier
- Income tax e-filing portal and GST portal login access
- Return, computation of income and tax audit report for the year, where applicable
- GSTR-1, GSTR-3B, GSTR-2B and annual return for the GST period in dispute
- Books of account, ledgers, bank statements and trial balance
- Invoices, agreements, vouchers and confirmations supporting each disputed item
- Hearing notices, remand reports and any correspondence from the department
- Challan or proof of any pre-deposit or payment already made against the demand
- Details of the financial position and recovery notices, if a stay of demand is needed
- Proof of reasons for delay, such as medical records or portal logs, if the appeal is late
- Earlier appellate orders or judgments you or we intend to rely on
- Authorisation or vakalatnama for representation, where required
How Peter and Co. handles a tax appeal (step by step)
- Order review
We read the order, record the date of communication, check which forum applies and confirm the limitation.
- Merit assessment
We assess each addition or demand, tell you where the case is strong or weak, and discuss alternatives to appeal.
- Pre-deposit and stay planning
We work out any pre-deposit and whether a stay of demand should be sought, and prepare that application.
- Grounds and statement of facts
We draft numbered grounds of appeal and a dated statement of facts in plain language for your review.
- Paper book and evidence
We compile an indexed paper book and, where needed, an additional-evidence application with reasons.
- Filing
After your approval, we file the appeal in Form 35 or on the GST portal, or with the Tribunal, and keep the acknowledgement.
- Written submissions and hearing
We prepare written submissions and case law, and represent you at the hearing as the forum's rules permit.
- Order and rectification
We analyse the order, apply for rectification of any apparent mistake and follow up on the effect given.
- Next forum
Where advised, we prepare the next-level appeal and coordinate with counsel for the High Court.
Frequently asked questions
What is the time limit for filing an income tax appeal before the CIT(A)?
Under the Income-tax Act, 1961, an appeal to the Commissioner (Appeals) is generally due within 30 days from service of the notice of demand or the order, with discretion to admit a late appeal for sufficient cause. Peter and Co. checks the date of service on your order before advising.
How do I file an income tax appeal online?
You log in to the Income Tax Department e-filing portal, select the appeal facility, fill Form 35 with the order details, grounds of appeal and statement of facts, attach the order and submit with verification. Peter and Co. prepares the grounds and files it for you, and tracks hearing notices.
What is an ITAT appeal?
An ITAT appeal is the second appeal to the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal against an order of the CIT(A) or another specified order. The Tribunal can examine facts and law, and its order can be taken to the High Court only on a substantial question of law. Peter and Co. prepares and argues ITAT appeals.
Is there a pre-deposit for an income tax appeal?
A first appeal to the CIT(A) does not carry a fixed statutory pre-deposit like GST, but the demand remains payable unless a stay is obtained, and a part payment is often asked for. Peter and Co. advises on the stay application and the amount to propose.
Where do I file a GST appeal?
The first GST appeal is filed with the Appellate Authority under section 107 of the CGST Act, through the GST portal, with the order, grounds and pre-deposit. A second appeal goes to the GST Appellate Tribunal. Peter and Co. prepares and files GST appeals and confirms current procedure.
What is the time limit for a GST appeal?
The first appeal is generally to be filed within three months from the date of communication of the order, with a limited further period that the Appellate Authority may allow for sufficient cause. Later stages have their own limits. We confirm the exact date for your order.
Does filing an appeal stop recovery of the demand?
For GST, recovery of the balance disputed amount is generally kept in abeyance after the required pre-deposit. For income tax, an appeal alone does not automatically stop recovery, so a stay of demand is usually requested. Peter and Co. prepares the stay application with your appeal.
Can a delayed appeal be accepted?
Sometimes. Appellate forums can condone delay if you show sufficient cause with an honest, supported explanation, but it is not a right and the extra period in some statutes is limited. File within time wherever possible. Peter and Co. prepares the condonation application where delay has occurred.
What is a paper book in an appeal?
A paper book is an indexed and page-numbered compilation of the documents you rely on in the appeal, such as the return, computation, bank statements, agreements and earlier replies. It helps the Tribunal or authority find each document quickly. Peter and Co. prepares it with a clear index.
Can you guarantee that my appeal will succeed?
No. Peter and Co. cannot guarantee any appellate outcome, because it depends on the facts, evidence, law and the view of the authority. We promise a careful order review, well-drafted grounds, a complete paper book and diligent representation, and we will tell you honestly where the case is weak.
Can you handle both the notice reply and the appeal?
Yes. Our income tax litigation and GST litigation teams handle notices, replies and assessment hearings, and the same firm prepares the appeal if an adverse order is passed. This keeps the facts and documents consistent across stages.
Send us your query
Tell us what you need and which city you are in. Our team replies during office hours (Mon–Sat 10:00–19:00). Prefer to talk? Call +91 98911 05177.