GST litigation is the handling of a dispute with the GST department, from a notice or show cause notice through reply, personal hearing and the adjudicating officer's order, and onward to appeal if needed. Peter and Co., a tax firm in Laxmi Nagar, Delhi, reads your notice, reconciles your returns, files the reply on the GST portal and represents you at the hearing.
Key facts
- Governing law
- Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017, State GST Acts and the IGST Act, read with the GST Rules
- Where notices appear
- The "Additional Notices and Orders" and "View Notices" areas of your GST portal login, usually with an email or SMS alert
- Common notice forms
- ASMT-10 (scrutiny), DRC-01 (show cause), REG-17 (cancellation), RFD-08 (refund)
- Common reply forms
- ASMT-11, DRC-06, REG-18 and RFD-09, filed on the GST portal
- Order forms
- ASMT-12, DRC-07, REG-19 and RFD-06, depending on the proceeding
- First appeal
- Appellate Authority under section 107 of the CGST Act; see our appeals page
- Representation
- Reply, personal hearing and written submissions by our team; appearance rules depend on the forum
- Service mode
- In person at our Laxmi Nagar office by appointment, or online across India
Peter and Co. provides GST litigation services from our office in Laxmi Nagar, Delhi, for traders, manufacturers, service providers, e-commerce sellers, contractors and companies that have received a GST notice. A GST dispute rarely starts as a dispute. It usually begins as a short notice on the GST portal asking you to explain a mismatch, and becomes a demand with interest and penalty if the reply is late, weak or never filed.
This page explains the kinds of GST notices, how a GST notice reply is prepared and filed, what happens at adjudication and the personal hearing, which orders can follow, and where an appeal fits in. If you are looking for a GST litigation consultant near you in East Delhi, Shahdara, Preet Vihar or Karkardooma, you can meet our team in person by appointment, or we can handle your matter online from anywhere in India. The content reflects the position as of October 2026 and is written in general terms, because limits and procedures are amended from time to time.
What is GST litigation and when does a GST notice become a dispute?
GST litigation is the process of contesting or resolving a disagreement between a registered person and the GST department over tax, input tax credit, interest, penalty, registration or refund. It covers the notice stage, the reply, the hearing before the adjudicating officer, the order, and any rectification or appeal that follows.
A notice is not yet a demand. A notice states what the officer believes is wrong and invites your explanation. The dispute becomes a demand only when an order is passed confirming tax, interest or penalty. That is why the quality of the first reply matters: the officer decides largely on what is on record, and a later appeal is generally argued on the same facts and documents.
Peter and Co. treats every GST notice as a documentation exercise first and a legal argument second. We establish what the department has relied on, what your books and returns actually show, and which of the differences are real and which are timing or data-entry issues. Only then do we decide whether to accept part of the liability, contest all of it, or seek time to produce records.
GST disputes are handled by the proper officer under the Central or State GST Act, depending on which administration your registration falls under. Some notices also come from audit and anti-evasion wings. The forum, form and time limit differ, so the first task is always to identify exactly who has issued the notice and under which provision.
Who needs a GST notice consultant or GST legal consultant?
Any registered taxpayer who receives a notice that asks for an explanation, a payment or a document should get the notice reviewed by a professional before replying. The need is greater where the amount is large, the issue is legal rather than clerical, or the notice has a short reply window.
- Traders and wholesalers whose input tax credit does not match what suppliers filed.
- Manufacturers and exporters facing queries on credit, refund of unutilised credit or classification.
- Service providers and contractors with questions on place of supply, rate or works contract treatment.
- E-commerce sellers whose turnover in GST returns differs from marketplace or TCS data.
- Transporters and traders in transit whose goods or vehicles were stopped and a notice followed.
- Taxpayers whose registration is under cancellation, often for non-filing of returns or a failed physical verification.
- Applicants whose refund was rejected in whole or in part.
- Companies and LLPs that need a legal consultant for GST who will keep the board and statutory auditor informed of contingent liabilities.
If your matter is purely about filing returns or registration, our GST registration and filing team may be the right starting point. If the notice has already become an order against you, read our page on income tax and GST appeals.
What are the main types of GST notices and replies?
The main GST notices are scrutiny of returns, show cause notices for demand, notices for cancellation of registration and notices on refund claims. Each has its own form number on the GST portal, its own reply form and its own kind of order.
| Situation | Notice form | Reply form | Order form |
|---|---|---|---|
| Scrutiny of a return, discrepancies pointed out | ASMT-10 | ASMT-11 | ASMT-12 (acceptance) or further proceedings |
| Show cause notice for tax not paid, short paid or credit wrongly availed | DRC-01 (with a statement in DRC-01 or an attachment) | DRC-06 | DRC-07 (summary of the order) |
| Proposed cancellation of registration | REG-17 | REG-18 | REG-19 (cancellation) or REG-20 (dropped) |
| Proposed rejection of a refund claim | RFD-08 | RFD-09 | RFD-06 |
| Intimation of tax ascertained before a notice, with option to pay | DRC-01A | DRC-03 payment or reply | Notice may follow if unresolved |
Form numbers and portal layouts are updated by the GST Council and the GST Network, so we check the current portal before filing. Some matters, such as search, seizure or summons under the Act, follow different procedures and are not covered by this table; send us the document and we will tell you which track it belongs to.
What is a GST show cause notice (DRC-01) and how do sections 73 and 74 work?
A GST show cause notice is a written notice from the proper officer asking you to explain why tax, interest and penalty should not be demanded from you. It is issued on Form DRC-01 or with a statement in the related form, and it must state the grounds, the period and the amount proposed.
Under the CGST Act, notices for tax not paid, short paid, erroneously refunded or input tax credit wrongly availed have traditionally been issued under section 73 where there is no fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression, and under section 74 where the department alleges fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts. Section 74A has been introduced for later periods and brings the two situations into a single framework. As of October 2026, which section applies depends on the financial year of the dispute, so we confirm it for your notice.
Why the section matters
- The time within which the department may issue a notice and pass an order differs between the sections, and the limit is counted from a date set by the Act. We calculate it from the facts of your case; we do not rely on a single rule of thumb.
- The penalty and the chance of settling by paying tax and interest before the order differ between sections. Where fraud or suppression is alleged, the consequences are heavier, so the department must show the ingredients, not merely assert them.
- A notice that does not state the grounds, mixes several periods without clarity, or is issued beyond the permitted time can be challenged on that basis alone.
Our team reads the notice for validity first: who issued it, under which section, for which period, within what time, and whether the facts alleged are supported by the attached statement. Many replies begin with a preliminary objection and then answer each ground on merit, so that both legal and factual positions are on record.
How do you reply to a GST notice for ITC mismatch between GSTR-2A, GSTR-2B and GSTR-3B?
An ITC mismatch notice says that the input tax credit claimed in your GSTR-3B is higher than the credit shown as available in GSTR-2A or GSTR-2B, which are statements built from your suppliers\' returns. The reply is a reconciliation: for each supplier and invoice, show whether the credit was genuinely eligible and why the figures differ.
GSTR-2A is a dynamic statement that changes as suppliers file; GSTR-2B is a static monthly statement. The law on how credit is matched has been amended over time, and there are conditions for taking credit such as receipt of goods or services, a valid tax invoice, tax actually paid by the supplier and filing of the return by the recipient. We therefore examine each condition separately and do not treat a mismatch as automatic proof of wrongful credit.
Typical reasons for a mismatch
- The supplier filed the return late, so the invoice appears in a later month.
- The supplier reported the invoice under the wrong GSTIN, period or document type.
- Credit notes, amendments or reverse charge entries were not matched in your books.
- Credit was taken in a different month from the one in which the supplier reported it.
- Ineligible credit that you should have reversed, for example on blocked items.
- The supplier has been cancelled or has not paid tax, which needs a separate legal position.
Our team prepares a supplier-wise and invoice-wise reconciliation, collects tax invoices, e-way bills, transport and payment proof, and drafts a reply that explains each difference. Where part of the credit is genuinely ineligible, we advise whether to reverse it with interest and show it as voluntarily paid, which can narrow the dispute. Avoid a blanket statement that "all credit is genuine" without supporting records.
How are scrutiny, e-way bill, registration cancellation and refund rejection notices handled?
Each of these notices has its own procedure, but the approach is the same: identify the provision, collect the proof the officer needs, reply on the portal within the time given and attend the hearing. The documents and arguments, however, are different for each.
Scrutiny of returns (ASMT-10)
The proper officer scrutinises returns and sends ASMT-10 pointing out discrepancies, for example between GSTR-1, GSTR-3B, GSTR-9 and the books. You reply on Form ASMT-11 with an explanation or by correcting the position and paying any tax and interest. If the officer is satisfied, the proceeding ends; if not, a show cause notice or an audit may follow. GST assessment through scrutiny therefore decides whether a matter closes quietly or escalates.
E-way bill and transport issues
Goods in movement can be inspected, and where documents are missing or incorrect the vehicle may be detained and a notice for tax and penalty issued. The usual disputes involve an expired or mismatched e-way bill, wrong vehicle number, invoice and e-way bill value differences, and goods different from those described. We examine whether the defect is a technical error or a substantive one, and prepare a reply with the invoice, e-way bill, transport record and any correction made. Time is critical because goods and vehicles are held until the matter is resolved or security is furnished.
Registration cancellation notices (REG-17)
A registration can be proposed for cancellation for reasons such as non-filing of returns for a continuous period, non-existence at the declared place of business, or alleged fake invoicing. Reply on REG-18 with proof of the business address, filed returns and an explanation. If cancellation has already been ordered, there is a separate application route for revocation, subject to time limits, which we confirm for your case. Cancellation affects your customers\' credit, so act promptly.
Refund rejection (RFD-08)
Before rejecting a refund, in whole or part, the officer issues RFD-08. Typical grounds are mismatch of invoice details, ratio of inverted duty, export documents and time limit. We reply on RFD-09 with the working, shipping or bank realisation proof and the legal basis. If the refund is rejected by order, the next step is an appeal; see our appeals page.
What happens at GST adjudication, the personal hearing and the order?
GST adjudication is the stage at which the proper officer considers the notice, your reply and the records, hears you, and passes a reasoned order. The law requires the officer to give you an opportunity of being heard before an adverse order, and the order must deal with your submissions.
Personal hearing
The hearing is usually fixed by a notice on the portal and may be held in person or by video conferencing, depending on the office. A hearing is where the officer asks questions and you can explain the reconciliation. We prepare a short written submission, an index of documents and a list of the points we want on record. If a date is inconvenient, a written request for adjournment should be filed in advance and acknowledged.
Types of orders
| Outcome | What it means | What you can do |
|---|---|---|
| Proceedings dropped | The officer accepts your reply and closes the notice | Keep the order and documents safe; check the portal shows it |
| Demand confirmed in full or part | Tax, interest and penalty are ordered, with the amounts in the summary order | Pay, or review for appeal and rectification within the time limit |
| Ex-parte order | Passed on the records because there was no reply or no attendance | Seek advice immediately; an appeal or other remedy may be available, depending on facts |
| Registration cancelled | Registration ends from the date stated | Consider revocation application or appeal, within time |
| Refund rejected | Claim denied in whole or part | Review the grounds and consider appeal |
Read the order carefully for the amount, the period, the heads (tax, interest, penalty), the date of communication and the appeal route. The date of communication is the date from which appeal time is generally counted, so we record it on the first day.
Can a GST order be rectified, settled voluntarily or appealed?
Yes, three routes are generally open: rectification of a mistake apparent on the face of the record, voluntary payment of tax and interest to reduce or close a notice where the Act allows it, and an appeal to the Appellate Authority. Which route fits depends on the nature of the error and the time that has passed.
Rectification
If an order contains an arithmetical or clerical error, or ignores a document that is plainly on record, the officer can be asked to rectify it. Rectification is for obvious mistakes, not for re-arguing the case, and it must be applied for within the time stated in the Act. Where it is not the right tool, an appeal is.
Pre-litigation payment and settlement options
The GST law allows a taxpayer in some situations to pay the tax and interest, and sometimes a reduced penalty, either before a show cause notice is issued or within a stated period after it, and thereby conclude the proceeding on those terms. The conditions, the percentages and the cut-off dates differ by section and have been amended, so we confirm the current position before advising. Paying does not mean admitting every allegation, but you should understand exactly what the payment closes and what it does not.
Appeal
A person aggrieved by an order of the adjudicating officer may appeal to the Appellate Authority under section 107 of the CGST Act, generally within a time limit counted from communication of the order, with a pre-deposit of a part of the disputed tax. Further appeal lies to the GST Appellate Tribunal and then to the High Court on questions of law. Time limits, the pre-deposit and the forms are explained on our income tax and GST appeals page.
What are the common mistakes in a GST dispute?
The costliest mistakes are ignoring a notice, missing the hearing and replying without a reconciliation. Each one tends to turn a manageable query into a confirmed demand.
- Ignoring the notice. A notice that is not answered can lead to an ex-parte order, and a demand with interest and penalty. Even a short interim reply is better than silence.
- Missing the portal alert. Notices are served on the portal, and an old email address or mobile number means you may not see them. Check your GST portal login regularly.
- Not attending the personal hearing or not asking for an adjournment in writing.
- No reconciliation. A general denial without invoice-wise working is rarely accepted.
- Replying to the wrong notice or wrong period, or uploading documents that do not match the allegation.
- Paying without recording the basis. A payment through DRC-03 should state whether it is voluntary or under protest.
- Admitting liability in the reply without first understanding the legal consequences.
- Missing the appeal limit after an adverse order, because the date of communication was not recorded.
- Relying on supplier assurances. A supplier\'s promise to file a return late is not a substitute for records.
Most of these are preventable by a monthly check of GSTR-2B against the books and a regular look at the portal. Our GST filing and accounting teams can build this into your routine.
What affects the cost of GST litigation services?
The fee for GST litigation depends on the work involved, not on a fixed price list. Peter and Co. quotes after reading the notice and understanding the records, and we do not publish amounts on this page because two notices that look alike can need very different effort.
- The amount and the number of periods in dispute, and whether several notices are combined.
- The type of notice: a simple ASMT-10 differs from a multi-year show cause notice with fraud allegations.
- The volume of reconciliation, such as the number of suppliers and invoices to be matched.
- The state of your records: well-kept books reduce time, while missing invoices and unreconciled data increase it.
- The number of hearings and whether the forum is in Delhi or another city.
- Legal complexity, such as classification, place of supply or a jurisdictional challenge.
- Whether an appeal or later stage is included in the engagement or taken separately.
- Urgency, since a very short reply window needs prompt allocation of staff.
Government fees, if any, and the pre-deposit for an appeal are separate from professional fees and are paid to the government, not to the firm. We give an estimate in writing before starting so you know what is included.
Why Peter and Co. in Laxmi Nagar, Delhi, for GST litigation, and what can we not promise?
Peter and Co. is a tax, audit and compliance firm at Office No. 816, 8th Floor, Laxmi Deep Building, Laxmi Nagar District Centre, Delhi 110092. You can call or message us on +91 98911 05177 during office hours, Monday to Saturday, 10:00 to 19:00. We meet clients in person by appointment from Laxmi Nagar, Shahdara, Preet Vihar, Mayur Vihar, Anand Vihar, Karkardooma, Krishna Nagar, Noida and Ghaziabad, and work online with clients across India.
The same firm handles your GST returns, your income tax and your audit, so the person replying to a notice can see the full picture of your books. Where a matter moves from reply to appeal, our team prepares it in continuity through the appeals practice.
Limitations and what we cannot promise
We cannot promise that a notice will be dropped, a demand reduced or an appeal allowed. Outcomes depend on the facts, the records, the law and the view of the officer or tribunal, and no consultant controls them. We also cannot guarantee that an adjournment or extension will be granted. What we can do is analyse the notice honestly, tell you the strengths and weaknesses, prepare a complete reply and represent you diligently. Some forums may require representation by an advocate or an authorised representative, and we will tell you if that applies.
Related services
Many GST disputes link to other work: GST registration and filing, income tax litigation, tax advisory and consulting, accounting services and tax audit. You can also read about our full range of services or contact us for a first discussion.
This page is general information, not legal advice; rules change, so we confirm the current position before acting on your case.
Documents required for a GST notice reply or litigation matter
- The GST notice or show cause notice with all annexures, statements and the date of service
- GSTIN, portal login access and the registered email and mobile number
- GSTR-1, GSTR-3B, GSTR-9 and GSTR-9C for the period in question
- GSTR-2A and GSTR-2B downloads for the relevant months
- Sales and purchase registers and the ledger extracts from your books
- Tax invoices, credit notes and debit notes for the disputed entries
- E-way bills, lorry receipts, transport documents and proof of delivery
- Bank statements and payment proof for supplier payments
- Electronic credit, cash and liability ledgers from the GST portal
- Registration certificate, rent agreement or ownership proof of the place of business
- Refund application, shipping bills, FIRC or BRC and related working, where refund is involved
- Earlier replies, orders, acknowledgements and correspondence with the department
- Supplier details and any communication confirming filing or payment of tax by them
How Peter and Co. handles a GST notice or dispute (step by step)
- Review the notice
We read the notice and annexures, identify the section, period, amount, issuing officer and the reply and hearing dates.
- Check validity and limitation
We check whether the notice is properly issued, within the time allowed and clear on its grounds.
- Collect records
You share returns, registers, invoices and ledgers through our checklist, and we download portal data with your authorisation.
- Reconcile the figures
We match the department figures with your books, supplier by supplier and invoice by invoice, and mark each difference.
- Decide the position
We discuss with you whether to contest, accept in part, pay voluntarily or seek more time, and explain the consequences.
- Draft and file the reply
We prepare the written reply with legal grounds and exhibits and upload it on the GST portal before the deadline.
- Attend the hearing
We prepare a short submission and represent you at the personal hearing, in person or by video, as the office permits.
- Review the order
We read the order, record the date of communication and advise on payment, rectification or appeal.
- Move to appeal if needed
Where appeal is advised, our appeals team prepares the grounds, statement of facts and paper book.
Frequently asked questions
What should I do first if I get a GST notice?
Read the notice and its annexures, note the reply and hearing dates, and do not ignore it. Share it with Peter and Co. so we can check the section, the period and the amount against your returns. A timely, documented reply is usually the best protection against an ex-parte order.
What is a GST show cause notice?
A GST show cause notice is a written communication from the proper officer asking why tax, interest and penalty should not be demanded from you. It states the grounds and the amount proposed. It is not a final demand; you can reply, be heard and the officer then passes an order.
Is a GST notice the same as a GST demand notice?
Not exactly. A notice or show cause notice proposes a demand and seeks your reply. A demand arises when an order confirms tax, interest or penalty. People often say "demand notice" for both, so Peter and Co. first checks which stage your document represents.
How do I reply to an ITC mismatch notice?
You reply with an invoice-wise reconciliation of the credit claimed in GSTR-3B against GSTR-2B or GSTR-2A, with tax invoices, payment proof and an explanation of each difference. Where credit is genuinely ineligible, reversal with interest may be advised. A general denial without records seldom works.
What happens if I do not reply to a GST notice?
The officer may pass an order on the available records without hearing your side, called an ex-parte order, confirming tax, interest and penalty. Remedies exist but are harder and time-bound. Replying on time, even with a request for more time, keeps your options open.
Can I get more time to reply to a GST notice?
You can request it in writing, and the portal permits adjournment requests in some proceedings, but whether it is granted is the officer's decision. Do not wait for the answer. Peter and Co. usually files a holding reply on time and supplements the documents later.
Do I have to attend the personal hearing?
You or your authorised representative should attend, in person or by video as the notice permits. The law requires an opportunity of being heard before an adverse order. If the date is unsuitable, ask for an adjournment in writing in advance. Non-attendance can lead to an order on records alone.
Can I pay tax and interest to avoid further proceedings?
In some situations the GST law allows payment of tax and interest, sometimes with a reduced penalty, before or soon after a notice, to conclude the proceeding. The conditions and percentages differ by section and have been amended. Peter and Co. confirms the current position and explains what the payment will and will not close.
What if my GST registration is proposed to be cancelled?
You should reply on the portal to the show cause notice (REG-17) with proof of your business address and filed returns, within the time given. If cancellation is ordered, a revocation application or appeal may be possible within a time limit. Peter and Co. checks which route is open.
Where do I appeal against a GST order?
The first appeal against an adjudicating officer's order lies to the Appellate Authority under section 107 of the CGST Act, within a time limit counted from communication of the order, with a pre-deposit. Further appeal goes to the GST Appellate Tribunal. See our GST appeal services page.
Can you guarantee that my GST notice will be dropped?
No. Peter and Co. cannot guarantee any outcome, because the result depends on the facts, your records, the law and the view of the officer or tribunal. We promise a careful review, a complete and timely reply and honest advice on strengths, weaknesses and next steps.
Send us your query
Tell us what you need and which city you are in. Our team replies during office hours (Mon–Sat 10:00–19:00). Prefer to talk? Call +91 98911 05177.